There are various kinds of ice cream makers so much so that getting the best electric ice cream maker can be a herculean task. We took out longs hours to research on different types of ice cream makers before settling on these products that we are reviewing today.
If you are a home chef that loves to make ice cream, a parent who have kids that always require some frozen treats or just a lover of ice cream then you need to pay close attention to this piece.
So many people spend a lot of money on ice cream and other frozen treat. But we feel that a wiser investment of that money spent at an ice cream shop can be made in purchasing an ice cream makers. That is why we are bringing you these products that come in different models and at different price ranges.
Top Quality Commercial Value Product For Serious Home Chefs
Product Name – Lello Musso Pola 5030 Dessert Maker
Our Rating – 4.3 out of 5 stars
- Has a 2 quart capacity
- Can produce 6 quarts of ice cream in an hour
- Durably constructed with top quality stainless steel housing and blade
- Has a classic finish
- Proudly made in Italy
The Lello Musso Pola 5030 Dessert Maker is a high end ice cream maker that’s ideal for folks who want the highest quality of homemade ice cream. It can also serve as an add-on machine for folks who run a small restaurant or ice cream parlour.
This machine is designed with an inbuilt freezing unit that doesn’t require any ice or salt. This therefore means that your ice cream production is mess-free!
The Lello Musso Pola 5030 Dessert Maker is a power horse in the sense that it produces 2 quarts of ice cream in not more than 20 minutes. Additionally, it doesn’t need to sit or have any bowl pre-frozen before you can make subsequent batches. This invariably means that you can churn out batch after batch of your desired frozen treat without interruption.
This feature also makes it ideal for parties or events where you need large batches of frozen treats.
The material used in making this machine is such that lends itself to durability. So you are sure to get your money’s worth from this product.
More so, the quality of ice cream that this machine produces is restaurant chef quality. So if you are particular about the texture and quality of your ice cream, then consider investing in this machine. The truth of the matter is that it is by far the cheapest ice cream maker that’s in the league of commercial value ice cream makers!
High End Home Use Electric Ice Cream Maker
Product Name – Whynter ICM-200LS Stainless Steel Ice Cream Maker
Product Name – 4.2 out of 5 stars
- Comes with a highly efficient CFC-free compressor
- Has a trustworthy inbuilt audible timer
- Comes with a BPA-free aluminium bowl that is removable
- Churn blade is also removable which makes for ease of storage and cleaning
- Motor operates at 180 watts and has a voltage of 110/120V 60Hz
The Whynter ICM-200LS Stainless Steel Ice Cream Maker is an alternative that is more suited for a home. It is also a high end machine that churns out top quality ice cream and other frozen desserts.
This machine however comes in at a way cheaper price point than the previous product we reviewed. The price however does not make it any less efficient; the only thing is that it is strictly a home product.
It comes encased in solid top quality stainless steel housing and has an aluminium mixing bowl that is removable. It is recommended that this machine be placed in an environment that is well ventilated and ensure that the temperature of the place is not below 90°F or above 60°F.
This machine is easy to use and clean as the mixing bowl and churn blade can be removed and cleaned without issues. The detachable nature of these items also makes the machine easy to store.
It works with a safety feature that shuts off the machine if the mixture freezes to a solid state. This helps to preserve the life of your machine. Furthermore, the extended cooling feature of this machine stops the mixture from melting after it has been churned.
The inbuilt compressor is powerful enough to work continuously for a long time. This means that you can make batch after batch of ice cream without any wait time. In addition to that, there is an audible timer that’s inbuilt into the machine that would alert the user when the churning cycle is up.
So with the 2-quart capacity of this machine, you have the capability to make ice cream/frozen desserts for parties or hangouts with friends and family. And you need not worry about learning to use this machine; it is quite easy to use with the control panel that is soft touch LCD and the recipe guide.
Finally, there is a complimentary ice cream scoop to serve the delicious treat!
Best Seller Ice Cream Maker on Amazon
Product Name – Cuisinart ICE21R Ice Cream Maker
Product Name – 4.6 out of 5 stars
- Upgraded mixing paddle that makes ice cream/frozen desserts in not more than 20 minutes
- Made with top quality BPA free materials
- Comes with double insulated freezer bowl that doesn’t require ice
- Comes with a transparent lid that’s easy to lock in place
- Large pour spout makes it easy to add ingredients and make operation mess-free
The Cuisinart ICE21R Ice Cream Maker is a reasonably priced ice cream maker that gets the job done. It is on this list because it is the current best seller on Amazon. This ice cream maker has garnered over 7,000 reviews from verified users and is rated a 4.6 average.
In keeping with the Cuisinart tradition of excellence, this machine is top quality machine that is easy to use. It is fully automatic and comes with all the features that make for mess and stress free operation.
No learning curve is required with this machine; all you need to do is throw your mix into the bowl, put on the machine and let it work its magic.
Cuisinart upgraded the mixing paddle (which has a patent that’s still pending) to be able to churn out a batch of ice cream in not more than 20 minutes.
The heavy duty motor is strong enough to power ingredients for any kind of frozen treat and the transparent cover allows you to watch the progress of your mixture.
With the rubber feet of this machine, there is an assurance of the machine remaining in place as it churns the mixture.
This machine is generally rated as one of the easiest machines to use for homemade ice cream. However, it is advised that you read the user manual first before you start using it ( as should be the case for every product too!)
Finally note that this machine requires that you pre freeze the mixing bowl at least 16 hours before use and must be used immediately the mixing bowl is brought out of the freezer. This machine is not for those who like to make ice cream on a whim, you have to plan ahead. One way you can always be prepared to use this machine at short notice is by always leaving the mixing bowl in the freezer.
Bucket Design Ice Cream Maker With Large Capacity
Product Name – White Mountain Electric Ice Cream Maker with Appalachian Series Wooden Bucket (PBWMIME612-SHP)
Our Rating – 4.3 out of 5 Stars
- Has a 6-quarts capacity
- Housing of handmade new England pine wood is held together by galvanized hoops that’s strong enough for enhanced durability
- Comes with a 12,000 rpm motor
- Dasher system employs triple motion action to produce smooth and creamy texture in frozen treats
- Canister and lid are made with top quality stainless steel
This White Mountain Electric Ice Cream Maker is a large capacity machine that’s beautifully designed with handmade New England pine wood bucket. It is designed in such a way that it is easy to carry along to wherever you want to use it. This makes it ideal for a day out at the beach with friends and family.
The ultra-strong motor and triple motion action dasher system combine to make short work of any ice cream or frozen treat recipe. This in turn produces as much as 6 quarts of ice cream between 20 to 40 minutes.
The materials used in manufacturing this ice cream maker are of top quality and food safe. They are also designed for durability.
The dasher system is a patent of White Mountain and is made of heavy duty cast iron that is electroplated to make it last longer. This ensures that the dasher system does not lose its shape. In addition to that, the beech wood blades adjust as they turn to make sure that it evenly scrapes the mixture on the sides of the interior of the canister.
This ice cream maker requires the use of rock salt and ice but is easy to use and maintain.
Finally, it comes with a limited warranty of 5 years.
Bucket Design Of Ice Cream Maker With Lower Capacity
Product Name – Nostalgia WICM4L Electric Ice Cream Maker
Our Rating – 4.4 out of 5 stars
- Has a 4-quart capacity
- This unit is compatible with all Nostalgia ice cream accessories/kit
- Plastic bucket is easy to clean
- Operates with a powerful electric motor
- Comes with a transparent lid
The Nostalgia WICM4L Electric Ice Cream Maker is reminiscent of old fashioned ice cream makers. It is fitted with a strong electric motor that precludes the need for any manual labor by the user. This motor locks into place to keep all the parts of the unit secure.
All you need to do to get your ice cream/frozen treat is to dump your ingredients into the aluminium canister and put into the center of the bucket. After that, you layer with rock salt and ice and then turn on the motor to do the churning.
The lid of the canister is transparent which enables you to monitor the progress of your frozen treat. Then afterwards you can use the canister to store leftover frozen treat in the freezer.
There is no learning curve to this ice cream maker, just follow the recipe guide and instructions in the manual and you’ll have your frozen treats in less than an hour!
Product Name – AMERIHOME ICM6C 6-Quart Old Fashion Ice Cream Maker
Our Rating – 4.0 out of 5 stars
- Combo design provide versatility of function
- Has a 6-quart capacity
- Produces soft serve ice cream in half an hour(30 minutes)
- Comes with an aluminium canister that has a transparent plastic cover
- The casing is a sealed pine bucket/tub
The AMERIHOME ICM6C 6-Quart Old Fashion Ice Cream Maker is designed just like the forgoing 2 products that we have reviewed. However this ice cream maker differs in that it is both manual and electric. It comes with a hand crank that doesn’t require electricity and a motor that is powered electrically.
This dual functionality makes this product ideal for summer camps or hiking expeditions where you do not have access to electricity. Even when you are at home or have access to electricity, you can use the electric motor to produce soft serve ice cream and then use the hand crank to harden the ice cream after the churning cycle. This saves you the need to further place the ice cream in the freezer.
The casing of this unit is made of pine wood and designed like a tub and it is sealed for enhanced durability. The ice crusher ensures that the rock salt and ice remain separated while the mixing paddle prevents the ice cream mixture from moving. This allows the ice cream to set nicely and evenly.
This ice cream maker is easy to use as it comes with an instruction manual that also includes recipes that have been tested and proven. So you do not have to indulge in trial and error before you can start enjoying your homemade frozen treats.
Product Name – Maxi Matic EIM-1400R Ice Cream Maker
Our Rating – 4.2 out of 5 stars
- Comes with a simple freezing bowl
- Functions with a simple control panel
- Has a 1 ½ quart capacity
- Easily detachable parts that make for ease of cleaning
The Maxi Matic EIM-1400R Ice Cream Maker is a compact sized ice cream maker that produces satisfactory results for you and your loved ones. Sometimes people who live in apartments or have small kitchen spaces are hard pressed to get some kitchen appliances. They are most times left to make do with store bought items of things/food that they would otherwise have loved to prepare themselves.
With this ice cream maker however, you have a machine that doesn’t take up much space in your kitchen. In addition, it would give you the freedom to make customized frozen treats for you and your loved ones.
It is quite easy to use and clean; just read the instruction manual that comes with the product and you’ll be fine. It is a no-hassle ice cream maker! In 40 minutes or less you have your yummy frozen treat and all the parts are detachable which makes for ease of cleaning. Just read the instruction manual like we mentioned earlier.
Product Name – Dash My Pint Electric Ice Cream Maker
Our Rating 3.8 out of 5 stars
- Available in many colors
- Has a capacity for 1 ½ cups of ice cream
- Ideal for singletons
- Produces your frozen treat in not more than 30 minutes
- Easy to use and clean
The Dash My Pint Electric Ice Cream Maker is an ideal ice cream maker for singletons or folks that observe portion control. There is no reason why you cannot have that small quantity of homemade ice cream that you want. You no longer have to make a large batch of ice cream and keep the leftover in the freezer.
With this machine you make just the right quantity and save yourself the temptation of over indulging.
The compact size of this machine (it weighs less than 1 pound) makes it ideal for dorm rooms, RVs, camping trips and small kitchens. This machine frees you from not foregoing your guilty pleasure while not overindulging at the same time.
This product includes the following upon purchase: – a cooling bowl, a mixing spoon, access to database of recipes and a recipe booklet. In addition to that, it is backed by a manufacturer’s warranty for 1 year.
This ice cream maker would be a perfect wedding gift, housewarming or college dorm room gift. The user manual is quite easy to understand and would help you get the best out of your ice cream maker.
Before we round up this review, we want to leave you with some tips on how to choose the electric ice cream maker that’s best for you. We would however not go into full details because we have a previous article where we proffered a detailed buying guide. Click here to read it.
With that being said, let’s go ahead to share a few points in this segment.
Different Types Of Electric Ice Cream Maker
Knowing the different types of electric ice cream makers that are available is imperative to knowing which would work best for you. We are not saying that you must know all the technical nitty gritty but a basic knowledge would suffice.
To this end, we would share a summary of the workings of the 4 different types of electric ice cream makers that are available as of this day.
These are the types of ice cream makers that have a mixing bowl that has a liquid solution which has to be frozen before use. In most home freezers, the process of freezing the bowl adequately would take 24 hours. When the bowl is frozen, it is then placed in the machine and with the ice cream ingredients in the bowl.
The machine is powered by electricity and it does the churning of the ingredient into ice cream. These machines produce ice cream in 20 to 30 minutes and most of the end products have to be placed in the freezer to solidify more.
The disadvantage of these types of ice cream makers is that they can only make one batch of ice cream at once. This is because the mixing bowl has to be frozen ahead of time. The only way you can get a double batch at once is by having an extra mixing bowl. This would of course require extra space in your freezer for 2 bowls.
The advantage of these types of ice cream makers is that they are not expensive. The Cuisinart ICE21R Ice Cream Maker is a good example of this type of ice cream maker.
Small Ice Cream Makers That Fit Into A Freezer
These types of machines are placed in a freezer and plugged to a power source. The paddle of the ice cream maker stirs the mixture in the ice cream maker from time to time to prevent large ice crystals from forming. When the ice cream is ready, the paddle would stop mixing and lift off the mixture. This machine works in slow motion and takes a longer time to freeze the ice cream unlike the pre-frozen mixing bowl which in in direct contact with the cooling element.
What happens with these types of ice cream makers is that the likelihood of the formation of large ice crystals is higher because of the time it takes for the ice cream to set.
This is one disadvantage that makes these types of ice cream makers unpopular. Another disadvantage is the need to plug it to power source; this means that it can only work with a freezer that is built with space for such an attachment. Conversely there are models that work with rechargeable batteries which most people find expensive and not worth the stress.
These are ice cream makers that come with their own freezer so there’s no need for pre-freezing any bowl. All you need to do is plug the machine for a few minutes, dump your ingredient into the appropriate cavity and let the machine do the magic! Most of these machines get your ice cream ready 20 minutes, 40 max, depending on the size and type of recipe.
These types of ice cream makers are the most convenient to use and cam churn out multiple batches of ice cream without interruption however, they are amongst the most expensive home ice cream makers available.
The Whynter ICM-200LS Stainless Steel Ice Cream Maker is one of such machines.
These types of ice cream makers operate with an outer casing that’s filled with ice and rock salt and a canister that has a churner and scraper. These two elements are powered by an electric motor.
The operation of these types of ice cream makers is also simple. You add the ice cream ingredients in the canister and place the canister in the middle of the outer casing and layer with ice and rock salt. The motor then powers the mechanism that controls the rotation of the canister and scraper, while keeping the paddle stationary.
At the end of a churning cycle, you have your ice cream! These types of machines are not as expensive as the ones with built in freezers but not as cheap as the ones with bowls that need to be pre-frozen. So they are in the in-between price range. Note that with these types of ice cream makers, you must have ice and rock salt handy.
The Nostalgia WICM4L Electric Ice Cream Maker is an example of these types of ice cream makers.
Remember that the above is not a full explanation of how each of these ice cream machines function. It is just an overview to give you an idea of its ease of use, advantages and disadvantages.
This knowledge would help you know what would work best for you. However, this is just a snippet of all that you need to know to enable you get the best product for you so don’t forget to read our article on how to choose the best ice cream maker.
You would find out how size, capacity, power source and price among other factors would affect the choice of product that’s best for you.